« The Elegant Universe [String Theory] free video | Main | [Off-topic] CS Lewis on the problem of evil »

Comments

Mike Godfrey

Hi CC,
thanks for the link previously to Brian Greenes 'Elegant universe' I have been enjoying it.
Regarding string theory I wondered what your thoughts are on its status as Science?
As it seems that it will never be open to empirical verivication?
Also I may of asked you this before, but from a Christian POV doesn't string theory make the cosmological argument from design redundant ?
Also thanks for the link to stellarium Im downloading it now-hope it works on vista(not very open source I know).
cheers for the always intertesting blog ,
Mike

CC

Hi Mike,

Thanks for the comments.

On String Theory's classification as science, strictly speaking I think it shouldn't be (given that it cannot be verified, being beyond observation at the moment).

Just the same, I'm sure you've heard of ST's advocates saying that indirectly, ST is falsifiable, thus can be legitimately classified as science.

On the other hand, ST's critics (even non-Christians) have maintained that ST as of the moment should be classified as a philosophy for the reason earlier cited.

On ST making the design argument redundant, can you pls elaborate on this query some more?

On Vista, well good luck. I finally saw the light earlier and so switched to a Mac :)

Regards,

CC

PS - Like your site, too. I've added it in my blog list (left hand side :)

Mike Godfrey

Hi CC,
thanks for adding my blog,yours is on my blogroll,I also mentioned your site at:
http://stargazerslounge.com/index.php?topic=13519.0

Regarding string theory and its implications for intelligent design,I was under the impression that String theory predicts many universes,if so then that would make the fine tuning argument null and void.
Regarding Vista It works like a dream.
Thanks,
Mike

Todd K

I just started using Stellarium myself - a truly great app, and free to boot! I wish it could print star charts...having a hard time finding that for free on a Mac.

Thanks for the great blog - I've added you to my links!

Todd
http://rookiestargazer.blogspot.com/

CC

Todd, thanks for the note.

Mike, thanks for the feedback on Vista. Makes me look forward to using Windows again one of these days.

On string theory's prediction of a multiverse and its (effect of) invalidating the design argument, I share the opinion of apologists who invoke Ockham's razor as one of the answers.

If I recall correctly (somebody correct me if I'm wrong), the number of baby universes being predicted by string theory is way above than the number of atoms in our own universe.

Hence, it would appear to me that the multiverse hypothesis is offerring a cure that is worse than the (perceived) 'problem'.

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Working...
Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been saved. Comments are moderated and will not appear until approved by the author. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.

Working...

Post a comment

Comments are moderated, and will not appear until the author has approved them.

Search


Copyright

  • © Cosmology Curiosity

    ISSN 1908-1065